I carry my j frames around town, more than anything else. M640-1 (2 1/8") & a M&P 340 (1 7/8").
May be a bit more then you are looking to spend, but never the less, I'd recommend considering an Andrews Custom Leather "Saddle Style" for yours. Seriously doubt you would be disappointed.
Essentially, it's a very well designed pancake holster, that wraps around the hip - like the saddle on a horse. Most comfortable all day concealment holster I've ever owned. I use the tension hold (no retention strap) option. Very secure, & presents effortlessly. Fits like the proverbial glove.
So impressed, I've been selling off all of my long time favorite (excellent workmanship) Milt Sparks edc holsters, & replacing them with Andrews Saddle Styles.
In my experience, a well designed, quality construction holster will make the difference between carrying on a regular basis - or not.